---
title: "California says many franchise agreements violate state law"
url: https://burnaze.com/article/70610928-892c-493f-9aea-095cad01e136
source: "Nation's Restaurant News"
original_url: https://www.nrn.com/restaurant-franchising/california-says-many-franchise-agreements-violate-state-law
author: "Jonathan Maze"
category: "Franchisors"
industry: "Franchise Industry"
segment: "Franchisors"
topics: ["Regulation & legal"]
published: 2026-11-20T20:02:12.000Z
modified: 2026-11-21T00:01:41.813Z
image: https://eu-images.contentstack.com/v3/assets/bltea7aee2fca050a19/blt2fd212b696af6294/6b00a788f7674e37b59db78a/Dickey_s_Shutterstock_2.jpg?disable=upscale&width=1200&height=630&fit=crop
---

# California says many franchise agreements violate state law

**TL;DR:** California’s DFPI found that many franchise agreements violate state law regarding contract terms, highlighting backdoor fees, non‑disparagement clauses, and noncompete clauses. The agency has fined Dickey’s Barbecue Pit and Kickin’ Crab for violations.

*By Jonathan Maze, originally published in Nation's Restaurant News on 2026-11-20. [Read the original](https://www.nrn.com/restaurant-franchising/california-says-many-franchise-agreements-violate-state-law).*

## Story

California has toughened its franchise enforcement in recent months. Photo: Shutterstock

The State of California continues to take steps to increase its regulation of franchise businesses.

The state’s Department of Financial Protection and Innovation, or DFPI, this week said that a review of franchise agreements used across multiple states found that many of them violate California law regarding contract terms.

DFPI’s guidance noted that several terms commonly found in such agreements violate a law signed in 2022 designed to protect franchisees from certain business practices the state considers deceptive.

Among the contract terms that the agency highlighted are what it calls “backdoor fees.” DFPI suggested that franchisors sometimes sidestep obligations to report all fees they charge by requiring franchisees to use certain services or vendors at inflated prices, which earn franchisors kickbacks in the form of rebates.

The agency also highlighted non-disparagement clauses, which it called “gag orders.” Franchisors will use such clauses to keep franchisees from publicly tarnishing a brand. The U.S. Federal Trade Commission has said that such clauses can’t be used to keep franchisees from reporting wrongdoing to the government.

DFPI also said that noncompete clauses are not legal, even in franchise contracts.

“California is committed to protecting small business owners and ensuring that franchise buyers receive fair, transparent, and lawful agreements,” DFPI Commissioner KC Mohseni said in a statement. “Entrepreneurs invest significant money when they buy a franchise. They deserve honest information and contracts that comply with the law, not coercive clauses, hidden fees, or misleading statements about potential income.”

The agency said that franchisors that include such clauses in their agreements could be subject to enforcement action, including blocking such companies from selling franchises in the state.

DFPI has intensified its enforcement of franchise business recently, as “federal regulators continue to roll back enforcement of franchise protections,” the agency said.

The state has recently taken enforcement actions against a pair of restaurant franchises, including fines against the barbecue chain Dickey’s for concealing the number of locations that closed, and one against the Kickin’ Crab for making unregulated franchise sales.

## Entities

- Franchise Industry (sector)
- Papa Johns (company)
- Dickey's Barbecue Pit (company)
- franchise regulation (topic)
- U.S. Federal Trade Commission (regulator)
- contract terms (topic)
- California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (regulator)
- fines (topic)
- enforcement action (topic)

---
Originally reported by Jonathan Maze, Nation's Restaurant News (https://www.nrn.com/restaurant-franchising/california-says-many-franchise-agreements-violate-state-law). Summarized by Burnaze (https://burnaze.com/article/70610928-892c-493f-9aea-095cad01e136).
