The American Franchise Act has bipartisan backing but franchisees face a trade-off

The American Franchise Act, a bipartisan bill, would codify a narrower joint-employer standard, making it harder to hold franchisors liable for their franchisees' employees.

Read the original at Restaurant Business
The American Franchise Act has bipartisan backing but franchisees face a trade-off

Joint liability could finally be codified. | Credit: Shutterstock

The left and the right don’t usually see eye-to-eye on labor policy. So, the bipartisan backing of the American Franchise Act is notable.

Introduced last fall, the American Franchise Act would codify a narrower joint-employer standard under both the National Labor Relations Act and the Fair Labor Standards Act, making it harder to hold franchisors legally responsible for their franchisees’ employees.

But bipartisan backing doesn’t mean everyone in Congress is on board. The bill has attracted a group of Democratic co-sponsors, even as other Democrats and labor organizations have pushed back, arguing that the legislation would shield corporations from legal responsibility.

The National Labor Relations Board has flip-flopped on this issue so much over the years that it’s almost impossible to keep up:

  • Pre-2015: Franchisors generally needed to exercise direct control over franchisees' employees to be considered joint employers.
  • 2015: The Obama-era NLRB broadened the standard to include indirect and reserved control.
  • 2017–2018: The Trump-era NLRB attempted to reverse course, but its decision was vacated.
  • 2020: The NLRB formally adopted a narrower standard requiring substantial, direct and immediate control.
  • 2023: The Biden-era NLRB broadened the standard again, including indirect and reserved control.
  • 2024–2026: A federal court vacated the Biden-era rule before it took effect; the NLRB formally reinstated the 2020 standard in February 2026.

The American Franchise Act brings back the 2020 Trump-era standard, but it’s not just a copy-paste of that rule. The proposed legislation gets more specific about spelling out exceptions to this standard. For example, routine practices such as the enforcement of brand standards, operational hours, training and safety qualifications would not by themselves qualify as “exercising direct and immediate control” over employees.

The business community understandably wants to put an end to this constantly shifting definition of the joint-employer standard instead of it being used as political football between presidential administrations.

But just when it looked as though Washington might finally settle the joint-employer debate for good, the American Franchise Act hit another speed bump. The House was supposed to vote on the bill this week, but leadership pulled the procedural vote due to concern over low Congressional attendance.

Despite this hurdle, experts still agree there’s a strong chance the American Franchise Act will pass during the lame duck session before a new Congressional class is sworn in.

“All bets may be off once a new group takes over Congress in January,” Jamie E. Wright, employment lawyer and founder of Wright Law Firm, said. “However, I would imagine there is broad support from both franchisors and franchisees alike who would welcome some degree of uniformity regardless of who is in power.”

Stability is one of the major points of appeal for legislators, as it’s generally not beneficial for legal guidelines to change every four years depending on who is in the White House.

Support for the bill, from industry groups like the National Restaurant Association and International Franchise Association, and franchisee-facing groups like the Coalition of Franchisee Associations is largely centered on the autonomy of small businesses.

While you might not automatically think of the McDonald’s down the street as being a mom-and-pop business, many of them are. The changes this bill would make are not necessarily just about taking away legal responsibility from large companies.

On the other hand, the legislation has been criticized by many ranking Democrats, unions, and other labor groups. The AFL-CIO union, for example, argued that the American Franchise Act would limit collective bargaining power and reduce corporate accountability.

In short, it comes down to framing: Does the American Franchise Act promote franchisee independence or reduced corporate liability?

“Obviously, franchisees would benefit from being free to operate as they see fit,” Wright said. “However, they would also be exposed to greater amounts of liability as a result of being ‘independent.’ So, we want to be careful that they are not exposed to disproportionate liability, given the number and type of decisions the franchisor often dictates.”

Rep. Bobby Scott (D-Va.), who opposed the American Franchise Act, foresaw the issues that could arise from this legislation. He proposed an amendment that would provide some protection for franchisees. However, Franchisee Right of Action amendment, would have given franchisees a right of action to sue franchisors for damages if a franchisee is found liable for labor violations. However, the vote to add the amendment narrowly failed in committee.

Without this proposed extra protection for franchisees, the American Franchise Act still offers more stability for the business community and a clearer legal designation between the responsibilities of the franchisor and franchisee. Assuming the bill passes, franchisees will have won meaningful control over how they run their businesses. But they also will have lost some of the legal cushioning that being part of a larger franchise organization provides.

This story was originally published by Joanna Fantozzi in Restaurant Business on November 19, 2026. Burnaze summarizes and links to the original reporting.

Read the full story at Restaurant Business

Liked this? Get the week's franchise news, explained

  • Sunday 8 AM ET weekly + a monthly deep dive
  • Sections picked for the industries you follow
  • Every claim linked to its source. Free.

Free. We'll ask you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime.