TL;DR
Replay Sports Cards will open its first New York location on November 21 at 2156 Bellmore Ave in Bellmore, NY, owned by Rob Ansalone. The opening marks the brand's expansion into New York and is a personal milestone for co‑founder Mike Martin.
Replay Sports Cards (“Replay”) will open its first New York location on Saturday, November 21, bringing its community-focused approach to buying, selling, trading and grading cards to Long Island. Located at 2156 Bellmore Ave, Bellmore, N.Y. 11710, the new shop is owned by Long Island native Rob Ansalone, who is turning a lifelong passion for sports and collecting into a local gathering place for fans and families.
The opening marks Replay’s entrance into New York and extends the brand’s reach into one of the country’s most passionate sports markets. For Ansalone, a Merrick native, the shop is a chance to give Long Island collectors a dedicated space to connect, trade and share the hobby in a welcoming, community-first environment. The milestone is especially personal for Replay Co-Founder Mike Martin, who grew up in the same community, just minutes from the new shop.
Owner background
Ansalone spent several years as an insurance broker and previously owned a gym franchise before exploring his next entrepreneurial opportunity. While sports and collecting had always been a passion, his return to the hobby began when he reconnected with the cards he had saved from childhood. Sharing them with his son turned collecting into something the two could enjoy together, and that experience shaped his vision for the Bellmore shop.
“I’ve loved sports and collecting since I was a kid, but getting back into cards with my son reminded me how special this hobby really is,” said Ansalone. “There’s a real community of collectors on Long Island, and I wanted to give them a place to come together, trade, and pass the hobby on to the next generation.”
Shop launch
Ansalone was drawn to Replay because it gave him a way to enter the card shop business with the support, structure and collaboration of an experienced franchise team rather than building a shop on his own. His shared roots with Martin, who grew up in the same Bellmore/Merrick area, made the opportunity feel personal from the start.
“Opening a Replay shop in my hometown is a true full-circle moment for me,” said Martin. “I spent more than 20 years in this community, and the shop is about five minutes from the house I grew up in. Getting to bring one of our shops to the place that shaped me, and to do it alongside someone like Rob who shares those same roots, means the world. This is exactly the kind of place I would have loved to have as a kid.”
Expansion strategy
Growing the Hobby Across New Markets
Replay continues to expand its franchise network by partnering with entrepreneurs who combine a passion for collecting with a commitment to their local communities. Its model brings together buying, selling, trading and grading services with online sales, livestream commerce, and community events, giving collectors multiple ways to engage with the hobby both in-shop and online.
In this story
This story was originally published in Franchising.com on November 20, 2026. Burnaze summarizes and links to the original reporting.
Read the full story at Franchising.comLiked this? Get the week's franchise news, explained
- Sunday 8 AM ET weekly + a monthly deep dive
- Sections picked for the industries you follow
- Every claim linked to its source. Free.