When Franchise Technology Becomes a Legal Liability

Franchise technology can become a legal liability if it controls daily work, creates evidence of compliance, and infringes on franchisee autonomy.

Read the original at QSR Magazine
When Franchise Technology Becomes a Legal Liability

TL;DR

The article explains how franchisor‑controlled technology can create legal liability by performing daily work for franchisees, citing the 2025 Texas Supreme Court decision in Massage Heights Franchising v. Hagman and the earlier case of Ronquillo. It outlines court rulings that distinguish between permissible brand‑standard support and impermissible operational control.

A franchisee asks for help: a competitor down the road just adopted software that clocks workers in, prompts upsells, and reports every sale. The franchisor responds by rolling out its own version to every location. Years later, that software is the centerpiece of a lawsuit against the franchisee and the franchisor.

In that case and ones like it, plaintiffs may call their theory joint employment, vicarious liability, or agency, but each asks the same question: did the franchisor stay within the minimum standards that protect its brand, or did its control reach the franchisee’s day-to-day operations? The answer often depends on the kind of control at issue, as a review of more than 600 franchise decisions issued since 2020, from motions to dismiss through trial, shows. When courts relied on allegations that a franchisor’s control went beyond enforcing brand standards, and those allegations did not involve technology, they treated those facts as evidence of impermissible control roughly a third of the time. When the allegations involved the franchisor’s technology platform—an allegation that has been observed to occur 3 times more often since 2020—that figure rose to more than half.

Why Technology Is Different

A brand standard tells a franchisee what result the system expects: a clean store, a consistent product, a safe delivery. How to get there stays with the franchisee. Software may implicitly take that choice away. It may clock in the crew, script the upsell, and keep a timestamped record of each step. In other words, it may perform the daily work that standards are supposed to leave to the operator and create evidence that it did.

Massage Heights Franchising v. Hagman shows how far brand standards can go. There, the franchisor required franchisees to run background checks on massage therapists, controlled the draping method therapists used, specified their training, detailed how they should interact with clients, and set protocols for responding to sexual assault allegations. After a franchisee’s therapist allegedly assaulted a customer, a jury found the franchisor negligent. In 2025, the Texas Supreme Court reversed, finding that the franchisor’s alleged control was not enough for it to be held liable.

Ronquillo v. Doctor’s Associates shows the opposite. A worker at a Subway franchise sued the Subway franchisor under Illinois’s biometric privacy law. She alleged that Subway’s point-of-sale software, which the franchisor “exclusively controls,” captured workers’ fingerprints when they clocked in. In 2022, a federal court in Chicago refused to let the franchisor put the collection solely on its franchisee, and the claim went forward.

The difference between the two cases is not how much control the franchisor had. In Massage Heights, the franchisor set rules and left the work to the franchisee. In Ronquillo, the franchisor’s software did the work itself.

Using Technology The Safest Way

Courts have yet to decide whether a franchisor’s AI tool can make it liable for a franchisee’s workforce, and some assume that question will require a new analysis. It should not. The numerous decisions where franchisor technology was at issue provide plenty of guidance for how this analysis should proceed and what franchise systems can do to protect themselves:

  1. Provide Technology to Aid, Not Dictate, Operations. A court held that requiring franchisees to use one brand of point-of-sale system did not make them a national coffee chain’s agents, because that control did not reach the system’s “functionality or operation.” Similarly, a pizza franchisor required drivers to use its delivery app, but a court held that a tool that “mechanically aids deliveries” is not supervisory control. An automotive service franchisor, by contrast, allegedly required franchisees to follow its point-of-sale software’s service recommendations “without deviation,” and a court held those allegations sufficiently supported an agency relationship.
  2. Use Technology to Improve Brand Standards, Not Monitor Operations. A burger franchisor produced training videos for its franchisee but did not track whether the franchisee’s employees watched them, one reason a court found the franchisor was not a joint employer. Another pizza franchisor, by contrast, allegedly accessed its system remotely to monitor fingerprint use, and its franchisees’ workers’ claims went forward.

None of this means franchisees should stop asking for technology or franchisors should stop offering it. It means carefully designing tools, and the rollout memos, training materials, and vendor contracts that describe them, so the record shows standards and support rather than management. Franchisees that see a franchisor’s technology crossing that line should raise the issue with the franchisor and work toward a solution that keeps operational control in the franchisee’s hands. Before the next rollout, every system should ask one question of each feature: does it permissibly assist the franchisee in achieving brand standards, or does it impermissibly interfere with the franchisee in operating the store and supervising its employees?

Thomas O’Connell is a Partner at Buchalter LLP and Chair of the firm’s Franchise Practice Group. He advises franchisors on disclosure, registration, and compliance, and represents them in franchise disputes. He can be reached at [email protected].

In this story

This story was originally published by Ben Coley in QSR Magazine on November 19, 2026. Burnaze summarizes and links to the original reporting.

Read the full story at QSR Magazine

Liked this? Get the week's franchise news, explained

  • Sunday 8 AM ET weekly + a monthly deep dive
  • Sections picked for the industries you follow
  • Every claim linked to its source. Free.

Free. We'll ask you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime.