Replay Sports Cards Signs Lease for Upcoming Indiana Location

The lease signing marks a key milestone as Replay advances development of its Seymour location, bringing a modern, welcoming card shop experience to collectors and families across southern Indiana.

“Opening a Replay location in Seymour is exactly why we built this brand,” said Brent Schepel, Co-Founder of Replay. “We’re creating spaces that feel authentic to the hobby. Spaces where knowledgeable service, trust, and community come first. Josh and Jason understand what collectors want, and we’re excited to see them bring Replay’s standards and energy to Seymour.&rdquo

Replay’s upcoming Seymour shop will be designed as a community hub for collectors of every level, with opportunities to buy, sell, trade and participate in events that make the hobby more accessible and enjoyable. The store plans to host activities such as trade nights, family-friendly events, box breaks, and special promotions that create a consistent reason for collectors to gather.

“For us, this isn’t just about opening a store: it’s about building something Seymour can be proud of,” said Stigdon. “We want a place where people can stop by after work, bring their kids on the weekend, and feel comfortable whether they’re chasing a big hit or opening their very first pack. Signing the lease makes it real, and we can’t wait to get the doors open.”

The store’s mission is to grow the hobby locally while making it welcoming and fun for everyone.

“The best card shops are the ones that bring people together,” said Buckel. “We’re focused on creating that kind of environment in Seymour. A store with a great selection, fair deals, and a calendar of events that keeps the community engaged. We also plan to collaborate with local teams and organizations so Replay can be part of what’s happening in town.”