TL;DR
Casey’s has built a pizza program that emphasizes made‑from‑scratch dough, hand‑made pizzas, and a digital ordering and loyalty system that integrates the Casey’s app and Rewards program. Brad Haga, Casey’s SVP of prepared food and dispensed beverage, explains that the brand focuses on consistency, quality, and value to drive pizza sales in convenience stores.
Brad Haga, SVP of prepared food and dispensed beverage at Casey's, talks pizza trends, insights and strategies for success.
As retailers look ahead to 2027, pizza stands apart as a key opportunity to drive foodservice sales. But success requires more than adding pizza to the menu. Consistent execution, quality ingredients, compelling flavors and value are essential to earning customer loyalty.
CStore Decisions recently sat down with Brad Haga, SVP of prepared food and dispensed beverage at Casey’s, who told us about how the retailer is differentiating its pizza program after more than 40 years, from its made-from-scratch approach to digital ordering, loyalty and menu innovation.
Pizza category outlook
CStore Decisions (CSD): How would you characterize the state of the pizza category in c-stores heading into 2027? What are the biggest opportunities and challenges facing retailers?
Brad Haga (BH): We tend to focus more on Casey’s and our guests. What I can say is that guests do not grade pizza on a curve because it came from a convenience store. Great pizza is great pizza, wherever it is served. The opportunity is to deliver restaurant-quality food with the speed and convenience this channel is built for. The challenge is doing that consistently, every day and at scale.
That consistency starts with our team. Through Casey’s Pizza Certification, we train the team members making our pizzas on the Casey’s Pizza Method, so there is one standard and one method behind every pizza we serve. At Casey’s, that means continuing to earn the guest’s trust with pizza that is made fresh, tastes great and delivers a strong value every time they visit.
Consumer trends and flavor
CSD: What consumer trends are having the biggest impact on pizza demand? Are there certain flavor profiles or offerings that are overperforming?
BH: Guests are certainly paying closer attention to value, but quality is not a trend. It is the expectation, and it always has been. At Casey’s, we have built our pizza reputation throughout more than 40 years by making our dough from scratch every day and serving an abundant and craveable pizza at a great value.
At the same time, guests want both the familiar and the unexpected. Pepperoni remains our top seller, while distinctive offerings like Breakfast Pizza and Taco Pizza continue to set Casey’s apart. Limited-time pizzas like our Bacon Cheeseburger and Barn Burner Chicken, which is a build developed by a Casey’s team member, give us room to explore bolder flavors while always listening closely to what our guests tell us. The winning formula is not chasing every trend. It starts with a quality pizza and finding a way to make the flavor uniquely Casey’s.
Pricing, portion, promotion
CSD: How are inflation, ingredient costs and labor challenges influencing pizza pricing, portion sizes and promotional strategies?
BH: Those pressures are real, and every food business has to manage them. But one thing we will not do is trade away the quality that built our reputation. We have been making pizza the hard way for more than 40 years: dough made from scratch every day, quality ingredients and pizzas made by hand in our stores.
One advantage of Casey’s broader business model is that pizza does not stand alone. Prepared food, grocery and fuel work together, which gives us more ways to create value for our guests. That lets us stay disciplined about pricing and promotions while continuing to serve the quality, abundance and consistency people expect from Casey’s. For us, value doesn’t mean “cheap.” It means the guest feels good about what they get for what they spent, and that’s why so many continue to choose Casey’s.
Launching and loyalty
CSD: If a retailer wanted to launch a pizza program in 2027, what are the first three areas you would recommend evaluating?
BH: Ask the question … is your food great? That’s the most important thing.
Making great pizza is not easy. At Casey’s, we do it the hard way: dough made from scratch every day and pizza made fresh by hand in our stores. We have been at it for more than 40 years, so we have learned that there really are no shortcuts. Guests do not care whether a pizza came from a traditional restaurant or a gas station. They care whether or not it’s good.
After quality, the questions are whether you can execute it consistently and whether your team believes in the program. A great recipe will not build a business if it is prepared differently from one location or one shift to the next. You have to be willing to do the hard things consistently at scale.
CSD: How are you using loyalty to enhance your pizza program?
BH: Everything we do starts with the guest, and their experience begins well before they walk through our doors. Our original made-from-scratch, thin and pan crust pizzas are all made to order, so digital ordering is a natural part of making that experience as easy and convenient as possible.
The Casey’s app and Casey’s Rewards bring ordering, savings and loyalty together. Members can earn points on everyday purchases in the store, online and at the pump, while receiving added value on pizza and other offers. That matters because our guests are often trying to solve several needs at once: fill up, grab what they need for the day and get dinner on the table. Loyalty helps us make that entire trip more convenient and more rewarding.
CSD: Is there anything in particular we should know?
BH: People who know Casey’s often think of us as a restaurant first, and that is not an accident. Walk into one of our kitchens and you will see dough mixers, pizza ovens, commercial equipment and team members making food fresh every day. It’s a restaurant operation, even if there happens to be a fuel canopy outside.
We have spent more than 40 years building that credibility, but we are not standing still. We have a talented culinary team that is constantly testing, learning and listening to our guests, along with thousands of pizza makers who bring it to life in our stores. We will keep protecting the classics people love while finding new, sometimes unexpected, ways to serve what they want. That blend of restaurant-quality food, innovation and everyday convenience is what makes Casey’s different.
In this story
This story was originally published by Kevin McIntyre in CStore Decisions on November 20, 2026. Burnaze summarizes and links to the original reporting.
Read the full story at CStore DecisionsLiked this? Get the week's franchise news, explained
- Sunday 8 AM ET weekly + a monthly deep dive
- Sections picked for the industries you follow
- Every claim linked to its source. Free.
