TL;DR
Angry Crab Shack's Director of Franchise Operations Ginni Naegle and Slutty Vegan's Founder and CEO Pinky Cole advise restaurant brands to conduct regular heart‑check conversations with managers to reduce turnover. Black Box Intelligence reports that replacing a general manager costs about $17,651, with training accounting for more than half of that cost.
Communication is one key to manager retention as restaurant brands can’t wait for an exit interview to find out someone is not happy. Instead, they should routinely have heart-check conversations and focus on building strong teams and not just filling positions, suggested Ginni Naegle, Director of Franchise Operations at Angry Crab Shack.
“Turnover does not happen overnight; there are signs weeks and months before someone quietly quits or resigns. Operators should be looking for warning signs, behaviors, energy, and negativity.”
At times, operators can get so caught up in sales and food costs that they forget to ask their team, “Are you good?” or “What do you need from me?” offered Pinky Cole, Founder and CEO at Slutty Vegan
“Talk to your people. Ask them how they’re doing before there’s a problem. And when they tell you, do something about it. If they keep bringing you the same problem and nothing changes, eventually they’re going to leave.”
Manager churn is now the industry’s biggest retention risk, according to Black Box Intelligence, and replacing a single general manager costs about $17,651, with more than half of that cost going to training alone.
While there are multiple reasons for turnover, leadership is often the number one reason people decide to leave any job, Naegle said, adding that other factors include the opportunity for growth and development within the company as well as benefit packages and competitive salaries,
“People stay when they feel valued, supported, fairly compensated, and there is room to grow.”
Burnout is another challenge, Cole noted.
“You’ve got one manager covering shifts, dealing with customers, managing the team, and then we’re asking why they’re frustrated. The pay has to make sense for what you’re asking them to do. And they need support. You can’t expect somebody to care for your business when they don’t feel taken care of themselves.”
Positive influence, leadership presence, team mindset, and coachability are among the qualities Naegle looks for when hiring managers.
Other factors include:
- Someone who is able to take responsibility without excuses or placing blame.
- Someone who can make everyone around them better, not just the people who are already great at their jobs.
- Someone who brings solutions, not just present problems.
When it comes to financials, they are looking for someone who is financially aware, accountable, and can adjust when business changes or things don’t go as planned while still making a responsible profit.
“They can lead, by example, knowing when to step in and get involved. They have a strong work ethic and can lead by example. Someone people naturally gravitate towards when looking for direction. They are the reason people want to work and keep everyone engaged.”
Cole looks for somebody who takes initiative.
“If you see something that needs to be done, do you handle it, or do you wait for somebody to tell you? We can teach you how to make a burger. I need to know you can lead a team.”
It’s also important to pay attention to how they treat people, she said.
“Can you be corrected without getting defensive? Can I trust you when I’m not in the building? Those things matter to me.”
To develop managers from within, recognize potential and train beyond the job descriptions, Naegle recommended. And don’t wait until a position is available to begin the process.
“Develop your high potential people and give them the opportunity to grow and lead. Learn about the peers in your building and figure out how you can transition them into leaders.”
Just because somebody is great at their job doesn’t mean they know how to manage people and you have to teach them, Cole added.
“Now they’ve got to make the schedule, have uncomfortable conversations, and hold their friends accountable. That’s a lot. Let them work alongside somebody who knows what they’re doing, and stay close enough that they feel comfortable asking for help.”
Promoting to a management role should not be based on seniority or because a position needs to be filled, Naegle added. One benefit of manager development, she said. is that costs are greatly reduced, and you already know they have work ethic as well as what their strengths and development opportunities are.
“When you have the opportunity to promote from within, you strengthen the culture and loyalty of your team. It also improves retention and creates a reason to stay and grow. They can transition faster, and people feel invested and supported when given opportunities they are then more likely to invest back into the company.”
Cole loves giving somebody who’s already in the business an opportunity to grow because they know the restaurant, and the team gets to see that there’s somewhere to go.
Challenges of promoting from within can include the difficult transition to manage former coworkers, a possible lack of management experience and the ability to make decisions quickly. They can become overwhelmed and feel unsupported if there are inadequate development resources, so it’s important to have training in place, Naegle said.
Cole agrees that managing people you were just working beside can get tricky. You might have to correct somebody you’re friends with. We have to help people through that part, and we have to be honest about whether they’re ready.
Investment into your people is one of the most valuable operational investments you can make and the strongest way to build a stable management team, Naegle said, adding that spending as little as three hours a month on DO/GM/Training team lead workshops greatly improves the health of your business in addition to manager retention and overall turnover. Categories should include communication and conflict resolution, business financial acumen, to include labor, COGS and overall responsible profit, team building and leadership classes, food safety, compliance and any certifications that apply and any individual developmental needs.
Overall, an annual manger development investment program to cover development, New manager promotions with training and labor coverage would range from $250 to $1000 per manager, she estimated.
Because you’re trusting this person with your business, teaching them how to run it should be a priority, Cole said. Stating one amount for every restaurant is tough because the needs are different, but it has to be in the budget.
“First, budget for their time. If somebody is training, who’s covering their shift? That costs money too. Then you’ve got certifications, hands-on training, and somebody spending time teaching them the numbers and how to manage people.”
In this story
This story was originally published by Barbara Castiglia in Modern Restaurant Management on November 17, 2026. Burnaze summarizes and links to the original reporting.
Read the full story at Modern Restaurant ManagementLiked this? Get the week's franchise news, explained
- Sunday 8 AM ET weekly + a monthly deep dive
- Sections picked for the industries you follow
- Every claim linked to its source. Free.
